602 Comments
User's avatar
Kathleen Rambo's avatar

I cannot “like” this article- but I truly appreciate you bringing this forward. I. Am. So. Angry. About what this administration is doing. Truly an assault on every damn front.

Thank you for the work you do.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

That anger is the correct response. What’s happening right now is the deliberate dismantling of American institutions that took generations to build. The “shining city upon a hill” is being looted from within.

Katarina Acsova's avatar

You are being cannibalized from within by the very American greed for land and 💰 that also destroyed Indigenous nations, enslaved black bodies, wiped out millions of bison and polluted water systems with chemical waste - never mind the environmental carnage American companies & armies have carried out world wide. Frankly, america has used "democracy" as a smokescreen to paper over the criminal and unfettered looting of this earth's natural resources. Your nation is not alone in this enterprise -- but the naked greed and corruption is on full display and it is breath taking in its scope and inhumanity. I weep for this planet and thank you for the work you do to protect it.

Suzi Kelley's avatar

I’m extremely ashamed of this administration and can’t imagine what they will do next. In a way our forests are the last frontier and hold precious wisdom we may not yet understand. This is a final blow for me. Trump must go. What can we do to save our country from total destruction? Saddest days.

KnoxAnn Armijo's avatar

Next is defunding daycare, taking away money from Medicare and Medicaid to pay for a war that would none of us want to kill people that we don’t know they aren’t doing anything to us.

Erin Q.'s avatar

Well said, Jim. I feel quite derailed and distraught most days, as I must continue to show up to work and participate in a system that is increasingly anti-life and so often rewards those with the worst impulses. It’s an inversion of all that is right and good. The vice grip of extractive consumption seems inescapable, yet the closing of the Strait of Hormuz may be a pivot point.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

You’re right about what you’re seeing. The mistake would be thinking you’re supposed to quietly endure it. You’re not. Systems don’t correct themselves. People force them to.

So don’t withdraw. Don’t numb out. Don’t play along more than you have to. Push back where you stand. Speak up. Make it harder for this to happen unnoticed. That’s the job now.

Bryan Mitchell's avatar

While I don't disagree with you my senators and house reps do not give two shits. Calling is useless I fear, it gets logged, maybe, and that's it. No people living around me here in Michigan, privileged people, give a shit. Its exhausting.

Lauren Boos's avatar

It’s literally one battle after another. I feel your pain, but you can’t give up. The aim is to wear all of us down.

Don’t do it…don’t let them get to you

Cathy Haustein's avatar

Well, my super conservative crusty Senator wrote back and hinted that he wasn't happy about it so give it a try. Plus, privileged people love to go hiking so I think this IS a privileged person issue. I also think you have a couple of good senators.

Bryan Mitchell's avatar

Maybe, but Slotkin is useless. A centrist & I even call her a republican cosplaying a democrat. Peters is retiring & doesn’t care. And ya, people living around me go about life as normal. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Katarina Acsova's avatar

It is the job. Thanks for your leadership and reminder. Having been an advocate for 40 + years - i am familiar with the draining dance of incremental change. But I am experiencing a new level of overwhelm these days. As a women I am slack-jawed at the rollback of gains, as an environmentalist- I weep for the ways my fellow humans have lost touch with the planet that sustains us. The international mafia of oligarchs have us drinking from a firehose of regressive stupidity and cruelty at every turn, and sometimes you just need to turn your head away to stop from being waterboarded by these monsters in human form.

PJ Schuster's avatar

I sincerely & deeply appreciate your many years of advocacy. I live in the middle of Lincoln National Forest in southern NM & have visited many other of our national forests & parks & I despise this. We humans truly do need these natural spaces for our very souls.

Unregulated capitalism is destroying the planet.

Kelli Kennedy's avatar

That’s what it is…being water boarded, and turning away. My heart feels so heavy with this terrible news.

Erin Q.'s avatar

Absolutely, Jim! Thank you for the poignant reminder.

E Shelton's avatar

“Sand in the gears” time. *

The court cases will come; court just ordered PBS funding restored because Congress legislated and funded it, like it did BLM. Because GOP are very nervous for 2026 with Trump’s lowering poll numbers and inflation. And Americans who aren’t loggers or miners like the forests. Want kids to have memories of them they have.

So please don’t give up! Erin, thank you for your hard work and caring.

*NSFW: search “OSS manual” if you don’t recognize the phrase; there are unofficial updates around, too.

Lauren Boos's avatar

And it’s easily printed 😄

Erin Q.'s avatar

Going to look up the manual you referenced, friend. 🙏

E Shelton's avatar

Glad to help. And it’s free. US government clandestine unit (Office of Strategic Services) published & distributed it in WWII for how people in Nazi-occupied countries can resist without getting killed.

How ironic that we can still access it for the same purpose. Spread the word — very carefully.

JLS's avatar

I’ve been getting gleeful financial alerts that “the largest transfer of wealth in US history is about to happen under Trump’s administration” and suggests “get in early to claim your share before this opportunity ends” and I’ve feared it had to do with gutting our public lands to hand over them over to private extraction industries. Money, money, money and the power it entails is all these people care about and it is their greed that drives their disastrous policies that are actively destroying our earth.

Please act now as Will is advising us to do. Our politicians need to hear from us loudly everyday! They want us to give up! Don’t let them win. Be part of the resistance and forward this story to everyone you know that loves public lands and the natural world they protect.

E Shelton's avatar

Sand in the gears time

Chrystie Munves's avatar

Looted is the right word!!!!!

Vanessa Benn's avatar

More like raped...like the pedofiles they are protecting 😡

Jemtl65's avatar

Me too! 🙉🙊🙈 I cant close my eyes to this atrocity!

Pielady1's avatar

Took the words from my mouth. Gasping for air here.

Kevin's avatar

Without trees, we all will be soon enough

KnoxAnn Armijo's avatar

It’s not just trees. It’s everything. They’ll turn over every rock and kill everything this wild. They’re in the money business, not the human business or the humanitarian business or the environmental business. I never voted for any of this in my entire life. I have spent my entire life, trying to protect the natural world and all that that’s in it.

Pielady1's avatar

truth. they are our air and water factories.

Jennifer's avatar

Genially, might I extend that just like every other social media platform, Substack uses the same "emotional" levers to boost content and help disseminate an author's note or publication—i.e., the more people see it, the more people read it, and the more people engage with it—especially when you have urgent, climactic, and dire rifle reports like this. "Liking"' is simply the vernacular for achieving this aim; it doesn't confer palatability or, not to be glib: "Yes, I enjoy reading about such devious, manifest, and wholesale devastation of our legacy of stewardship to the natural world." It is simply a sensor that reads a response and introduces more people to the post.

PAUL LIFE's avatar

You Americans took democracy for granted and stopped protecting and cultivating it, now your country is turning into an authoritarian regime worse than Russia.

Jennifer's avatar

I’m not sure I am the intended recipient of your distillation of my exchange with the other commenter. I don’t disagree with your premise, and can only hope for something better to emerge for us all following this not unforeseen political immolation.

E Shelton's avatar

Paul, we did. So now we’re working to fix that. Poland turned itself around, and that gives us hope — along with 47’s tanking poll numbers.

Lauren Boos's avatar

We were discussing this yesterday. His poll numbers are tanking, but do you think he cares? He’s a lame duck president anyway, and I believe his acolytes will distance themselves from him when the tide starts turning.

Linda Romero's avatar

We know. You don’t have to remind us.

Jemtl65's avatar

No, I don't think I'd say its turning away that far!

Jemtl65's avatar

Yes, very sad and tragic. I just hope there's something we can do to change things someday soon!

Kathleen Rambo's avatar

Thank you. I get it - yet there are a few posts that I simply can’t bring myself to hit that little heart button. I do leave a note of support for the author. Doesn’t happen often- but it does occasionally-

Dawn Reaume's avatar

I understand, not wanting to click the like button on articles that devastate you or are about something horrible that is happening.

I dealt with this for quite a while in the past feeling like if I hit the heart, it means I like the subject matter.

The way I think about it now is, I’m offering up a heart to the author & thanking him for the very thorough and detailed article. Thanking him for the knowledge he has given me about the subject. Also, making me aware of a situation that needs to be amplified so loud that it breaks through the noise & grabs the attention of all like-minded people. This needs to be done in order for the masses to begin, pushing back hard against the theft of our heritage, we were preserving to pass down to our future generations.

I am so heartbroken I have no understanding how some humans can have such stone, cold hearts. i’ve always been told I’m too emotional. The people that say that don’t understand the empathy I have

for all forms of life, that radiates from my soul.

It is our job to spread the news to every possible person we can.

Clicking the heart does this, it amplifies the authors writing for many more to become aware & help in making the pushback possible & massive.

These vile, wicked, people must be held accountable!

E Shelton's avatar

When that feeling hits, I remind myself that the heart means “I care about this.” Apparently, the algorithm notes it.

M.Wilson's avatar

Liking a story of real-time factual information doesn't translate into a solution of reversal in most cases. It's a case of after the fact that should never should of had to be written. The reporting of plans for public lands under this administration was exposed nearly a year ago. The protest for removal of the head of the snake that is allowing the destructive changes in this country never came.

America is that stupid kid that thinks it will never happen to me no matter how many ways you tell them. They have to see it to believe it. Then its too late.

Vicki K's avatar

This administration seems to get great satisfaction out of taking the wrecking ball to everything, and better yet for them if they can make a buck from it.

JJ Stein's avatar

I can’t hit that heart either

Roxanne's avatar

I am so furious 😡

Rennea Ashebyrne's avatar

We need to do something about it. Join the general strike US, sign a strike card on their website to add to the number of committed people so the strike can start in full. There is a network, a plan, regional discord servers….stop waiting for someone else to do something and take action yourself.

Louise M Riling's avatar

Exactly. Angry, furious, appalled, horrified

Kathleen Rambo's avatar

Power? I thought everything he did was to assert power-🤷‍♀️ (break things because he can)

I can’t imagine we are important enough to him for him to want us angry.

John Lewis's avatar

I believe anger is what Trump is going for with this. What other reason is there?

Ashley's avatar

I’m a Utahn. The anti-land movement here makes me sick. People singing Mike Lee’s and Governor Cox’s praises on this makes me even more sick. This is beyond heartbreaking.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

The overwhelming majority of Utahans don't support this either, but they keep voting for them anyway. That's another story of course.

Liberal Malcontent's avatar

Like red state ballot initiatives, you cannot support a position contrary to the priorities of the politicians you voted for. That's nonsense. Their support may come from indirect ignorance but it's still support.

They *do* support this.

Majharajha's avatar

I started my years with the Forest Service in the Wasatch Mountains of Utah. The destruction of public lands will be a scourge upon this country. Total greed and grift without integrity.

The Mongoose's avatar

As a proud utah RINO I will vote against Mike Lee forever. I need to write a sequel to my previous article about him, 'The Fig Leaf Senator.' This is bad.

David Walker's avatar

Seriously? We could do without the inference of violence.

The Mongoose's avatar

I have no idea what you're talking about. Voting is what we do INSTEAD of violence.

R J Rucker's avatar

I agree. Utah is one of our most beautiful states. Kiss the beauty and open space goodbye.

Rennea Ashebyrne's avatar

You have to actually do something about it. Join the general strike US, sign a strike card on their website to add to the number of committed people so the strike can start in full. There is a network, a plan, regional discord servers….stop waiting for someone else to do something and take action yourself.

Shelley Smyka's avatar

I agree with you. I am beyond sick!

KLMS's avatar

So sad that Utah has fallen SO LOW! 🤦🏼‍♀️💔

Kristi Spence's avatar

We spent our spring break last week in the Dixie National Forest between Grand Staircase Escalante and Capitol Reef. In Utah. On a trail with nothing around us but the waiting-to-bud aspens and melting patches of snow, my 9 year old asked me who takes care of these trails. “The forest service,” I told him. Tonight I am reading him this article and he reminded me of our conversation. “There will be no-one to take care of that trail now,” he realized, almost crying. And he is right. How this can happen is beyond me.

Will & Jim, thank you for this reporting, however bleak it is, and for mobilizing a community who cares about what Roosevelt and Pinchot knew needed protecting over 100 years ago.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

Kristi, that’s a gut-wrenching story. I’ve spent a lot of time in the Dixie. It’s one of the best kept secrets on our public lands. It pains me beyond measure to know that it and the rest of Utah’s national forests will now effectively be managed by the snakes in the state capital. And it pains me even more that they’re taking this nationwide now. So many good people will lose their livelihoods and their life’s work. And our forests will be ransacked if this works the way the administration hopes. We’ll fight this with everything we’ve got.

Will G's avatar

The Forest Service and National Parks fundings have been cut for years and no, they don't always take care of the trails which is why do many of us all around the country have volunteered to maintain them. This will make things worse.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 1Edited
Comment deleted
Kristi Spence's avatar

Thank you! I told him 💛Our forests is where we spend all the free time we have. As a family. This matters so much! 🌲

Vanessa Benn's avatar

They're like a plague of locusts stripping our forests and ravaging our natural resources until nothing's left. Unlike the locusts, eating to survive, these people are greedy gluttonous grifters. After they've polluted, consumed and destroyed everything for money 💰, it will be too late. Then they will realize they can't eat, drink or breathe the money they hoarded. 🤑 🤑 🤑

Peyton Roberts's avatar

Most of us look at a forest and see nature. This administration looks at a forest and sees $$$. I will be calling my senators. It is time to speak for the trees.

Peyton Roberts's avatar

Thank you for your irreplaceable reporting. Also I shared the Substack link and it is blowing up on Threads.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

Thanks a lot Peyton. Tune in tomorrow. This administration has its eyes on another prized piece of our public land unfortunately.

Peyton Roberts's avatar

NOT the news I was hoping to hear but it seems to be the trend 😭

JB's avatar

These people are cashing out our children’s future. When the living, breathing forest is gone it won’t be possible at any price to bring back what it does for us.

CatMintTea's avatar

Yes, we all need to speak for the trees.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 1
Comment deleted
Peyton Roberts's avatar

Dr. Seuss prepared us for a moment such as this.

Mark Martin's avatar

I had a 30 year career as an archaeologist and fire fighter with the Forest Service. I was proud of the work we did. Thank you for this article. I’m calling my senators (Bernie Sanders and Peter Welch) today and sharing this widely.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

Thanks Mark! For your service and for helping be the change!

Mark Martin's avatar

Thank YOU for doing the important work of keeping us informed so we can continue the fight!

Sally's avatar

Ditto. Botanist here. Everybody: Call your Congress Critters!

Jennifer Watson's avatar

I’m also a FS retiree of thirty years. As a Lands Program Manager in Wyoming and Montana, I worked to ACQUIRE land. Thank you Jim for so clearly stating the end game here. I will continue to work to inform folks in Montana who love their public lands here how dangerous this is for the places we all love. Too many here and throughout the nation have no idea.

Jolene's avatar

This makes me ill

Jim Pattiz's avatar

And it should I’m afraid. It’s devastating.

Lyn Heideman's avatar

And the announcement was made when Congress is on vacation for 2 weeks...

Your rep or senators may be holding a town hall, so a great chance to get not only their attention but everyone in the room.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

An excellent point Lyn

Mrs. S's avatar

Aha! Will do. My Washington state Rep. and Senators, all Democratic women leaders, are fully in favor of parks and forest lands. Those trees are now our state paid for public education for more than 125 years. My mom's cousin's husband was the head of the Walla Walla Forest Service office for a long time. He was a great human being.

Elizabeth J. Sampson's avatar

Are u kidding? They are vacationing while the rest of America cries..

Lyn Heideman's avatar

Congress likely didn't know, and Congress's spring break happens every year.

I've seen a pattern of anti-public lands/environment/wildlife announcements coming on a Friday night, around a holiday or an event like the Super Bowl, etc.--whenever people might be distracted. The goal is to exclude Americans from being aware of the announcements and/or from participating in public comments.

Another one: Chaco Culture National Historical Park opened up for drilling--announced April 1, public comments close April 7.

Another one: USFS "amended" (drastically curtailed) the process for public comments; announced Friday night; short comment period; and it worked as only ~2400 people commented.

We've seen Trump admin and Congress gut NEPA, ESA, etc. Bills such as the Fix Our Forests Act and the SPEED Act (currently in Congress...please let your reps know that you're a strong NO!) limit judicial review + ESA and NEPA. And they're going after public input with short comment periods and rule changes.

Interested in your thoughts...

Bill Lundeen's avatar

Grrrrr…😠😡🤬 WTF?!

Does anyone else hear the voice from the grave of Ed Abbey calling for the resurrection of the Monkey Wrench Gang? Is it time to dust off my old Eco-Terrorism 101? I hear the drumbeat…

Erin Q.'s avatar

YES!!! Amen, Bill. It’s definitely time to bang the drum and take action in the name of Edward Abbey!

Deirdre River's avatar

As reading was thinking we will all have to be Julia Butterfly Hill’s now.

Kara's avatar

Damn, these people!

Margaret Fleck's avatar

They look so self satisfied and arrogant

Corporate power has panted to exploit public lands

They have no conscience

💔💔💔💔💔💔

Heath Deaux's avatar

I just sent emails to all my FL reps and blasted a more refs on X. Here's hoping SOMEONE steps in and helps us fight this.

Pete Sween's avatar

That sickening little grin on Cox’s face… what a bastard.

Anne's avatar

These people and their vile plans are ruining everything, everything, all at once, and I despise them on a visceral level. Our poor children.

Sally Castle's avatar

This is absolutely horrifying, Jim. I can’t say we’re immune from it either - even in New Zealand we have a government that wants to “fast track” approvals that will destroy land and ocean reserves.

I just don’t understand that some people think that way. It’s a tragedy for our next generations.

Hoping so much that the campaign to stop this is successful. Warm regards to you from Aotearoa.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

Thanks Sally! We'll fight this tooth and nail.

Wendy O'Leary's avatar

Loud or loudly. Loud. And constant. We need to be loud and constant saying NO. To all those elected people who allowed this happen. These greedy pigs are just stepping right up while the keepers of democracy throw down fragrant rose petals in their paths. I have had it. An outrage too far.

Keith Mellett's avatar

Hard to put into words.

Jim Pattiz's avatar

Right you are Keith. This was a hard one to write. I've had the pleasure of working with so many wonderful people at the Forest Service over the years. I've stood in the Chief's office and looked at the painting of TR signing the bill that created the Forest Service. It's hard to contemplate what this will mean for so many good people let alone the public lands we all love and depend on.